If you’ve ever found yourself searching “social media manager vs agency”, you’re not alone. It’s one of the most common questions we hear from business owners and marketing teams looking to improve their online presence.
Social media is no longer a nice-to-have—it’s a business-critical marketing channel. But choosing who should manage your brand’s voice online isn’t always clear-cut. Do you build an internal team, or outsource to the experts? And what’s the true cost of each approach?
Let’s break it down.
The Real Cost of Hiring an In-House Social Media Manager
On the surface, hiring an internal Social Media Manager feels like the logical step. Someone who knows your business inside out, sitting just down the hall (or on Slack).
But here’s where many businesses get caught out.
In Australia, the average salary for a skilled social media professional with 3+ years’ experience sits between $75,000 – $100,000+ per year. And that’s before you factor in:
- Superannuation (11%)
- Annual Leave (20 days)
- Sick Leave (10 days)
- Payroll tax (if applicable)
- Hardware and software costs
- Training and development
- Onboarding and management time
When you add it all up, the real cost of a full-time social media hire often exceeds $120,000 per year.
And that’s for one person. One person expected to be a strategist, content creator, copywriter, community manager, ads expert, and analyst. Realistically, very few professionals can excel in all of those areas.
What You Get When You Hire a Social Media Agency
While partnering with a social media agency often starts from $4,000 – $10,000+ per month, the value stretches far beyond just “posting content.”
Here’s what you get:
Access to a Full Team of Experts
Instead of one generalist, you get a team of specialists:
- Strategists who map out how to meet your business goals.
- Content Creators who produce on-brand, scroll-stopping assets.
- Videographers who bring your story to life on TikTok and Reels.
- Paid Ads Managers who optimise your budget for real results.
- Community Managers who keep your audience engaged.
- Data Analysts who track performance and optimise accordingly.
Proactive, Data-Led Strategy
Agencies work across multiple industries and brands, giving them front-row seats to what’s working right now. You benefit from that collective knowledge, applied to your business before trends go mainstream.
Tools and Tech You Don’t Have to Pay For
No need to invest in scheduling platforms, reporting tools, premium editing software, or content production gear. Agencies bring their own toolkits—saving you thousands per year.
Flexibility to Scale With You
Unlike an employee, an agency can scale your package up or down as your needs change, without you needing to hire, train, or restructure your team.
Which Option is Right for You?
If your business is just starting out on social, and you have the resources to train and manage an in-house team member, hiring a Social Media Manager could work.
But if you’re looking for high-quality content, multi-platform strategy, and a full team of experts that can plug in and start delivering results right away – partnering with a social media agency offers far greater value for your investment.
Ready to See What Working With an Agency Looks Like?
At Melbourne Social Co, our packages are tailored to your goals and budget, with all the benefits of a full team, minus the overheads.
👉 Book a Free Discovery Call to chat with our team today.
